Hi NoahY,
I am facing the same issue while integrating your plugin (a better poll plugin) and I have tried resetting the poll options too. Anyways, seems like a CSS issue at least in IE, FF and Chrome. You can view the same at this link
http://bcdeka.com/deepthinking/12/1st-poll-1st-poll-1st-poll-1st-poll
Just for your information, the poll works absolutely fine for the poll creator (in my case only the admin), but breaks when viewed by others (registered users, guests etc).
Please let me know if you have any solution for this as this seems to be a very old issue (last comment in 2011) as of the complaint mentioned here:
http://www.question2answer.org/qa/9423/a-better-poll-plugin#c32761
Cheers
-Reep